Investing & Mutual Funds

Index Funds vs Active Mutual Funds in India: What the SPIVA Scorecard and Costs Tell Us

Over ten years, about three in four active large-cap funds in India have trailed their benchmark. Here is why, where the picture is different, and how to choose a good index fund.

Illustration for Index Funds vs Active Mutual Funds in India: What the SPIVA Scorecard and Costs Tell Us

Update 8 Oct 2026: Updated with SPIVA India Year-End 2025 figures and a new section on tracking difference and how to compare index funds.

Key takeaways

  • SPIVA India Year-End 2025 (S&P Dow Jones Indices) found that roughly three-quarters of actively managed large-cap funds underperformed their benchmark over ten years.
  • The main reason is cost. An active fund charging 1% more than an index fund must beat the market by 1% a year just to match it, every year, after trading costs.
  • Large-cap stocks are heavily researched, which makes consistent outperformance hard. Mid- and small-cap segments have shown better results for active managers in some periods, but with wide variation between funds.
  • Compare index funds by tracking difference (the gap between the fund's return and the index's total return), not just by expense ratio.
  • A common, sensible structure is a low-cost index fund as the core of an equity portfolio, with any active funds as smaller satellites chosen deliberately.

An actively managed fund employs a team to pick stocks it believes will do better than the market. An index fund simply buys every stock in an index, such as the NIFTY 50, in proportion to its weight, and does nothing else. The first approach costs more and promises more. The question every investor should ask is whether that promise is kept often enough to be worth the price.

What the SPIVA scorecard shows

Since 2014, S&P Dow Jones Indices has published the SPIVA India Scorecard, which compares the returns of actively managed Indian mutual funds with their category benchmarks. Two features make it more reliable than fund-house marketing: it includes funds that were closed or merged during the period (removing survivorship bias), and it compares each fund with an appropriate index rather than a convenient one.

The Year-End 2025 edition found that around 60% of active large-cap funds underperformed their benchmark in calendar 2025, and roughly three in four (about 76%) underperformed over ten years. Results for mid- and small-cap funds were more favourable to active managers in 2025, and have swung between good and poor years over time. Bond funds also fared poorly over longer horizons in the report.

Reading the scorecard correctly

"76% underperformed" does not mean the remaining 24% will outperform in future. Studies of persistence, including SPIVA's own, find that few funds stay in the top group year after year. Picking tomorrow's winners in advance is the hard part.

Why beating the index is so hard

1. Costs come first

The index return is earned before costs. An index fund tracking the NIFTY 50 typically charges 0.1% to 0.3% a year in its direct plan. An active large-cap fund commonly charges 0.7% to 1.2% in direct and 1.5% to 2% in regular plans. Add trading costs from buying and selling stocks, and the active fund must outperform the market by roughly 1% a year just to deliver the same result to you.

Lost corpus compared with an index fund earning 11.8% net; 20-year monthly SIP. Illustration only.
Extra yearly cost of the active fundOutperformance needed just to break evenWhat the cost removes from a ₹10,000 SIP
0.6%0.6% a year, every year₹7.53 lakh after 20 years
1.0%1.0% a year, every year₹12.18 lakh after 20 years
1.4%1.4% a year, every year₹16.56 lakh after 20 years

2. The large-cap market is crowded with professionals

The NIFTY 50 companies are followed by dozens of analysts each, and most of the trading in them is done by institutions. For one fund manager to beat the index, another participant must underperform it. When most of the market is professional, consistently finding mispriced large-cap stocks is difficult.

3. Size and mandate constraints

Large funds cannot easily take meaningful positions in smaller companies without moving prices, and SEBI's category rules require large-cap funds to hold at least 80% in the top 100 stocks. Many large-cap funds therefore end up close to the index in composition, while still charging active fees, a pattern sometimes called closet indexing.

Cost drag: ₹10,000 SIP in an index fund (0.2% TER) vs an active fund (1.2% TER) with the same gross returnAssuming both portfolios earn the same before costs, the index fund ends higher because of the lower expense ratio.₹0₹2L₹4L₹6L₹8L₹1CrY0Y4Y8Y12Y16Y20
Figure 1. If both funds earn the same before costs, a 1% higher expense ratio leaves the active-fund investor ₹12.18 lakh behind after 20 years on ₹24 lakh of contributions.

Where active funds have a better case

Index investing is not the answer to every question. Active management has more room to add value where markets are less efficient:

  • Mid- and small-cap stocks, which receive less analyst coverage and where a skilled manager can find mispricings. The flip side is a much wider gap between the best and worst funds, so choosing badly costs more.
  • Debt funds where credit selection and duration calls matter, although lower-risk categories such as overnight and liquid funds behave much like index products in practice.
  • Specific strategies (for example, value or quality styles) that some investors want and that are only partly available through factor index funds.

Even here, the evidence suggests keeping costs low and choosing funds with a long, consistent record across market cycles rather than last year's top performer.

How to choose an index fund

Most NIFTY 50 index funds hold identical portfolios, so the differences are small but real:

  1. Tracking difference. Compare the fund's return with the index's total return (which includes dividends) over one, three and five years. A smaller shortfall is better. This captures expenses, cash drag and trading costs together.
  2. Tracking error. The variability of that gap. Fund houses disclose it monthly; lower is better.
  3. Expense ratio of the direct plan. Small differences of 0.05% to 0.1% add up over decades.
  4. Fund size. Very small funds can have higher tracking error. Prefer funds with a reasonable asset base.
  5. For ETFs: liquidity. Check trading volume and the gap between the market price and the NAV (iNAV). A thinly traded ETF can cost more in spreads than it saves in fees.

A practical structure: core and satellite

Many investors combine both approaches. A low-cost index fund forms the core of the equity portfolio, often 60% to 80% of it, guaranteeing market returns minus a small cost. A few satellite funds, perhaps a mid-cap or flexi-cap fund chosen for a clear reason, make up the rest. This keeps overall costs low, limits the damage if a manager disappoints, and still leaves room for active ideas.

Whatever the mix, decide your asset allocation first: how much in equity, debt and gold. That decision affects your results far more than the choice between two large-cap funds.

The bottom line

In Indian large-caps, the evidence is clear enough to act on: most active funds have not beaten the index over long periods, mainly because of costs. A low-cost index fund guarantees you will not be among the laggards. If you choose active funds, do so deliberately, prefer direct plans, and judge them over full market cycles against the right benchmark.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an index fund and an ETF?

Both track an index. An index fund is bought and sold through the fund house at the day's NAV, and supports SIPs easily. An ETF trades on the stock exchange through a demat account at market prices during the day. ETFs often have slightly lower expense ratios but you pay brokerage and the bid-ask spread, and some ETFs have thin trading volumes.

Is NIFTY 50 or a broader index better?

The NIFTY 50 covers the 50 largest companies. Broader indices such as the NIFTY 100 or NIFTY 500 add mid- and small-cap exposure. There is no single right answer; many investors use a NIFTY 50 or NIFTY 100 fund as the core and add a separate fund for mid-caps if they want that exposure.

Do index funds protect me in a crash?

No. An index fund falls with the market. It removes the risk of choosing the wrong fund manager, not the risk of the market itself.

Why does SPIVA compare against S&P BSE or S&P India indices?

SPIVA uses benchmarks from S&P Dow Jones Indices, which co-own the BSE indices. The conclusions are similar against NSE indices because the large-cap universes overlap heavily.

Pradeep Rawal

About the author

Pradeep Rawal is an NISM-certified market professional (Series XV Research Analyst and Series VIII Equity Derivatives) with more than 15 years in personal finance and stock market education. He founded Financial Nirvana, wrote the book From Cubicles to Wealth Creation, teaches money and investing workshops, builds quantitative tools and backtesting systems, and writes about personal finance with the working shown.

More about the author · How we research and update articles

This article is for education only and is not investment, tax or legal advice. Tax rules quoted are for the tax year 2026-27 (FY 2026-27) unless stated, and can change; check the latest position with the Income Tax Department or a qualified professional before acting. Examples use assumed returns that are not guaranteed.